Tag: Apostles

The Greek word apostolos means ‘a messenger,’ or one sent forth with orders. The New Testament speaks of three groups of apostles: Jesus’ 12 disciples, those who saw Jesus after His resurrection, and a few others. What did they all have in common? They were either witnesses to Jesus’ ministry, or to His resurrection, or they were sent by those witnesses to preach the gospel.

Those who preach and teach something other than what Jesus taught are called “pseudo-apostles” by Paul.

  • How Did Jesus’ Apostles Die?

    How Did Jesus’ Apostles Die?

    It’s commonly believed that all of Jesus’ disciples, except John, were martyred… that is, killed for following Jesus. Unfortunately, these events aren’t as clear as we’d like them to be. Some seem to be well-attested in history while others rely on traditions, both oral and written. This alphabetical list has the best information I can find, for now. I’ll update the page as new information comes to light.

    Keep in mind that some of these traditions come LONG after the events, so the development of legends definitely comes into play here.

    Andrew

    Likely martyred. Accounts of Andrew’s death are a bit sketchy. He is said to have been martyred by crucifixion at the city of Patrae, in Achaia (Greece), in AD 60. The 6th-century apocryphal work Acts of Andrew describes him as bound, rather than nailed, to a cross. A later tradition says his cross was shaped like an X, which became known as Saint Andrew’s Cross. His remains were interred in Constantinople, then moved to the Cathedral of Amalfi, Italy.

    Bartholomew

    The manner of Bartholomew’s death is indeterminate. Foxe’s Book of Martyrs says that Bartholomew, also known as Nathanael, was beaten and crucified in India. Another tradition says that he was either beheaded or flayed alive in Armenia. His remains are thought to have been interred in St. Bartholomew Church, Rome, Italy.

    James (the son of Alphaeus)

    The manner of James’ death is indeterminate. Hippolytus (AD 170 – AD 235) wrote that James faced violent opposition from the Jewish community while preaching in Jerusalem, was stoned to death, and was buried near the temple in Jerusalem. His remains are believed to have been interred in St. James Church, Compostela, Spain.

    James (the son of Zebedee)

    Martyred. Acts 12 tells us that King Herod arrested members of the early church, intending to persecute them. James was executed by the sword in Jerusalem, at Herod’s command, around AD 44. It was about this time that King Herod arrested some who belonged to the church, intending to persecute them. He had James, the brother of John, put to death with the sword. His remains were interred in the Holy Apostles Basilica in Rome, Italy.

    John

    Died of natural causes, probably in Ephesus, around AD 100. Tertullian wrote that prior to his exile by the Romans, John was brought into a coliseum, immersed in boiling oil, and emerged unharmed. This, it was claimed, lead to the conversion of the entire coliseum to Christianity. John was later exiled to the island of Patmos. His remains were thought to be interred in St. John Basilica near Ephesus, Turkey.

    Judas Iscariot

    Suicide. Matthew 27 and Acts 1 tell us about Judas’ death. After betraying Jesus, the money he was given was used to buy a field. Matthew say that he hanged himself, while Acts tells us that he ‘fell headlong’ and his body burst open. Attempts to harmonize the two accounts suggest that after he hanged himself, the rope broke and his body fell to the ground.

    Jude

    The manner of Jude’s death is indeterminate. Also known as Thaddeus, tradition tells us that Jude was killed, along with Simon the Zealot, with an axe in Beirut, Lebanon around AD 65. His remains were moved from Lebanon in AD 1665 and interred in St. Peter’s Basilica, Vatican.

    Matthew

    Matthew likely died a natural death. Foxe’s Book of Martyrs records that Matthew’s missionary work included Ethiopia, where tradition says that King Hirtacus killed him with a halberd in AD 60. Other traditions make it unclear whether he was burned, stoned, or beheaded. His remains were interred in St. Matthew Cathedral, Messina, Sicily.

    Matthias

    The manner of Matthias’ death is indeterminate. Matthias replaced Judas Iscariot, who betrayed Jesus and then committed suicide. One tradition says that he was stoned to death in what is now modern Georgia, and was buried there. Another says he was stoned to death in Jerusalem, then beheaded. Hippolytus of Rome wrote that Matthias died of old age in Jerusalem. His remains are believed to have been interred in St. Mathias Abbey, Trier, Germany.

    Philip

    Philip likely died a natural death. One tradition says that Philip was crucified upside-down, along with Bartholomew. Another tradition says that he was beheaded. Both traditions maintain that he was killed in Hierapolis, in what is modern Turkey. His remains were interred in the Church of the Dodici, Rome, Italy.

    Simon Peter

    Crucifixion. Simon Peter was crucified by Roman emperor Nero in AD 64. Tradition says he requested to be crucified upside-down, as he didn’t consider himself worthy of being killed in the same manner as Jesus. His death was foreshadowed in John 21:

    “Very truly I tell you, when you were younger you dressed yourself and went where you wanted; but when you are old you will stretch out your hands, and someone else will dress you and lead you where you do not want to go.” Jesus said this to indicate the kind of death by which Peter would glorify God.

    The phrase “stretch out your hands” appears to be a reference to crucifixion. Eusebius quoted Origen as having written the following: Peter appears to have preached in Pontus, Galatia, Bithynia, Cappadocia, and Asia to the Jews of the dispersion. And at last, having come to Rome, he was crucified head-downwards; for he had requested that he might suffer in this way. Peter’s remains were buried in Rome, and the Church of St. Peter was built above to commemorate him.

    Simon the Zealot

    The manner of Simon’s death is indeterminate. Here’s a list of the different traditions of Simon’s death:

    • Simon was crucified in what is now England in AD 61.
    • Simon and Jude were killed in what is now Lebanon in AD 65.
    • Simon was crucified in Samaria.
    • Simon was sawn in half in Persia.
    • Simon died peacefully in Edessa.
    • Simon was stabbed with a sword.
    • Simon was martyred in Iberia.
    • His remains are buried at the Altar of Crucifixion, Vatican.

    Simon’s remains are said to have been interred in Nicopsia (Georgia), transferred to Anakopia (Georgia), and are believed to be at the Vatican… though some say the location of his remains are now unknown.

    Thomas

    Likely martyred. Known as Didymus (“the twin”), Thomas was killed with spears in Chennai, formerly known as Madras, India in AD 72. His remains were interred in St. Thomas Cathedral, Mylapore, India, with some relics being taken to Edessa (Turkey).

  • Is the Five-Fold Ministry False Teaching?

    Is the Five-Fold Ministry False Teaching?

    I’m often asked to assess what others teach. I do not do this lightly, but it is necessary. Before reading this page, or any of the pages about specific people, I recommend that you read What is a False Teacher?, which explains what the Bible says about false teachers, and why I would bother to research who they are and what they say. You may also want to check out a list of Bible Teachers I Can Recommend.

    I regularly get questions about those who call themselves ‘apostles’ or ‘prophets.’ My opinion is irrelevant, of course. The important question is whether anyone today should use those terms for themselves. In this article, I focus on the ‘apostle’ part of the five-fold ministry, to clear up the questions about modern-day apostles.

    The idea comes from Scripture

    The idea of the five-fold ministry comes directly from Ephesians 4:11 where Paul lists 5 (or four) kinds of roles that equip Christians for service. Here’s the verse, with some of its context:

    So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, to equip his people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.

    That’s good stuff. Here are the 5:

    • Apostles
    • Prophets
    • Evangelists
    • Pastors
    • Teachers

    I say there might be four because many scholars suggest that pastor and teacher should be combined as pastor/teacher. The number isn’t really important for our discussion. The question is whether the five-fold ministry, as expressed today, matches what we see in the New Testament. Keep in mind that there’s some variety of belief within those who teach about this, and that not everyone sees things in exactly the same way.

    Is it for today?

    Is the ‘five-fold ministry’ only found in the first-century church, or is it something that should be emulated and repeated today? It’s my belief that the five-fold ministry, as expressed by Paul in Ephesians 4, is a thing of the past. When I say that, I don’t mean that it’s no longer needed. I mean that it’s a historical thing, like Jesus’ birth and death and resurrection. Those are obviously still relevant today, but they don’t need to be repeated. To be clear: the New Testament doesn’t talk about apostles and prophets in the way that five-fold folks do, and that raises a red flag.

    The idea is that today’s church has these 5 ‘offices’ or roles, and that all 5 are needed to today. If this were true, then each church could have their own apostles and prophets. That isn’t what we find in the New Testament. Instead, ‘apostles and prophets’ refer to specific people who laid the foundation of the church… and that foundation is the same for every church, rather than being localized.

    This passage is in Ephesians 4. Let’s go back a bit to Ephesians 2 and see another place where Paul mentions apostles and prophets:

    Consequently, you are no longer foreigners and strangers, but fellow citizens with God’s people and also members of his household, built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the chief cornerstone.

    Note this phrase: “built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets.” The NIV (a fine translation) doesn’t quite capture what the Greek says. The NASB, a stricter word-for-word translation, expresses it more fully. They both express the meaning, but “having been built” is more precise than “built.” In context, Paul was saying that the Christians in Ephesus had been made one with the Jews because of Jesus, who made the two groups one. BOTH were built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets and “in Him the whole building is joined together.”

    The key is that the apostles and prophets were the foundation for both. The prophets for the Jews weren’t modern-day prophets, but Jewish prophets who warned Israel to return to God. The apostles weren’t modern-day prophets, but the apostles of Jesus… those who personally encountered Him while He ministered in Israel, who saw Him do what He did. THAT is the foundation on which the church has been built. Just as Jesus died and rose again and doesn’t need to repeat the process, so the work done by the apostles and prophets has been completed. The foundation of the church has been laid.

    The biblical definition of an apostle

    How do we know this? Let’s look at what happened after Judas betrayed Jesus and killed himself. The twelve had become eleven. They needed to choose a replacement for Judas, and here are the requirements, from Acts 1:17-22:

    Therefore it is necessary to choose one of the men who have been with us the whole time the Lord Jesus was living among us, beginning from John’s baptism to the time when Jesus was taken up from us. For one of these must become a witness with us of his resurrection.

    THAT is an apostle. They couldn’t replace Judas with just any old believer. They had to choose someone who could personally testify that they had witnessed Jesus in action. Paul wrote specifically in 1 Corinthians 15 about the ones to whom Jesus appeared:

    • Cephas (Peter)
    • then to the Twelve (the other 10 of Jesus’ closest disciples, minus Judas)
    • then to more than 500 of the ‘brothers and sisters,’ who were also disciples
    • then to James
    • then to all of the apostles
    • and last of all to Paul.

    Last of all to Paul. Now, Paul mentions several times that he’s not a typical apostle. Why? Because he didn’t follow Jesus when He was alive and ministering in Israel. The other apostles did. So, if Paul persecuted the church at that time, how could he be considered an apostle? It’s because He personally encountered Jesus after His resurrection, and was SENT (the meaning of the word ‘apostle’) to minister to the Gentiles by Jesus Himself.

    For verification: Luke, the writer of Acts, called Paul an apostle. Paul called himself an apostle in his writings, which Peter said were Scripture. The one common denominator in both the regular apostles and Paul, the atypical apostle, was that they saw Jesus alive after He had been killed and had been sent to teach others what He taught.

    The foundation has already been laid

    The church – everyone who has been born again, throughout all of history, all over the world – has been built on the foundation of the Old Testament prophets and the New Testament apostles. We have all we need for life and godliness in the Scriptures, in the one true gospel that was handed down once for all. Modern-day apostles and prophets can’t add to the gospel, or improve on it. We need no continuing revelation, which is the basis for the five-fold ministry.

    While there are lots of people who believe in the five-fold ministry that otherwise have orthodox theology, they can’t substantiate their position from Scripture. Instead – in my experience, and in the experiences of many others – those who consider themselves to be modern-day apostles and prophets both teach contrary to Scripture and go far beyond Scripture when they teach. For those reasons, I can never recommend an ‘apostle’ or ‘prophet’ as someone who can be trusted to handle Scripture responsibly.

  • What is the New Apostolic Reformation?

    What is the New Apostolic Reformation?

    I’m often asked to assess what others teach. I do not do this lightly, but it is necessary. Before reading this page, or any of the pages about specific people, I recommend that you read What is a False Teacher?, which explains what the Bible says about false teachers, and why I would bother to research who they are and what they say. You may also want to check out a list of Bible Teachers I Can Recommend.

    The New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) is a movement made up of a hundreds of churches and organizations around the world that call themselves Christian, but share a number of unbiblical ideas. Most NAR teachers are also Word of Faith teachers, another unquestionably unbiblical set of ideas.

    Movements are difficult to analyze and assess. Because a movement has no central authority, there are no official statements, and there is no official oversight. Individuals involved in the movement may have widely disparate beliefs, so valid criticisms for some are invalid for others. Because of the variations in belief and practice in any movement, each church’s or individual’s involvement with others in the NAR must be assessed independently of every other. The only reasonable goal here is to expose the errors and excesses, providing a correction for some and a warning for others.

    I see three paths for fairly assessing a movement like NAR:

    1. To look into the principles involved in the genesis of the movement,
    2. To critique what influential leaders in the movement have taught and written, and
    3. To examine the trends embodied in the movement.

    New Apostolic Reformation Founding Principles

    As with any movement, the NAR has had a variety of influences over the years. While not everyone in the NAR is Charismatic/Pentecostal, the movement is almost entirely in Charismatic/Pentecostal circles. Based on the teachings of some of its prominent leaders, the NAR has strong connections to previous, troublesome, Charismatic/Pentecostal movements. Here are a few of the commonly-held ideas taught by prominent leaders in the NAR:

    • God specially empowered new intercessors in the 1970s, new prophets in the 1980s and new apostles in the 1990s. 2001 marked the beginning of the ‘Second Apostolic Age.’
    • Men and women calling themselves apostles and prophets are elevated to positions of leadership based on supposed God-given authority in the church.
    • These leaders are to govern the worldwide church. That is, all Christians everywhere are to be under the authority of these ‘apostles’ and ‘prophets.’
    • These leaders are supposedly given supernatural powers, including the ability to provide new doctrinal revelation.
    • Supernatural manifestations, from tongues to raising people from the dead to mass conversions to heavenly conversations with Jesus or Adam or whomever, are to be expected (and are claimed by certain leaders).
    • These powers are needed to establish dominion over the earth, as God supposedly instructed in Genesis. This is variously understood on a spectrum, from having influence over culture to actually ruling God’s Kingdom here on earth, in our time.
    • They believe Jesus cannot return until the church has dominion over the earth. This process will necessitate the martyrdom of many as spiritual warfare increases.
    • Many NAR teachers follow the “Seven Mountain Mandate,” in which God has supposedly commanded them to take control of seven areas of society: government, education, church, family, media, business, and the arts. When this has been accomplished, they say, Jesus will then be able to return.

    Related people, movements, and theological concepts in the New Apostolic Reformation:

    • Beni Johnson (Bethel Church)
    • Bethel Church (Redding, CA)
    • Bethel Music
    • Bill Hamon
    • Bill Johnson (Bethel Church)
    • Bob Jones
    • Brian Simmons
    • Brownsville Revival
    • C. Peter Wagner
    • Cal Pierce
    • Cesar Castellanos
    • Ché Ahn
    • Chris Hodges
    • Chuck Pierce
    • Cindy Jacobs
    • Craig Groeschel
    • Dan Juster
    • Dan McCollam
    • Danny Silk
    • David Van Koevering
    • David Yonggi Cho
    • Dino Rizzo
    • Dominion Theology
    • Dutch Sheets
    • E.A. Adeboye
    • Elevation Worship
    • Ellyn Davis
    • Five-fold Ministry
    • Franklin Hall
    • G. Marie Carroll
    • George Warnock
    • Greg Surratt
    • Harvest Rock Church (Pasadena, CA)
    • Heidi Baker
    • Hillsong (Australia and worldwide)
    • Hillsong Worship
    • Ian Carroll
    • IHOP (International House of Prayer)
    • IMPACT Network
    • James Goll
    • Jane Hansen Hoyt
    • Jeremiah Johnson
    • Joel’s Army
    • John Benefiel
    • John Eckhardt
    • John Kelly
    • John Wimber
    • Johnny Enlow
    • Jonathan Welton
    • Judy Franklin
    • Jurgen and Leanne Matthesius
    • Kevin Gerald
    • Kim Clement
    • Kingdom Now
    • Kris Vallotton
    • Lance Wallnau
    • Larry Randolph
    • Latter Rain Movement
    • Lou Engle
    • Manifest Sons of God
    • Mark Chironna
    • Mary Banks
    • Mike Bickel
    • MorningStar Fellowship Church (Charlotte, NC)
    • New Life Church (Colorado Springs, CO)
    • Os Hillman
    • Patricia King
    • Paul Manwaring
    • Prayerwalking
    • Randy Clark
    • Ray Hughes
    • Rick Bezet
    • Rick Joyner
    • Robert Morris
    • Ron Cantor
    • Seven Mountain Mandate
    • Sid Roth
    • Spiritual Mapping
    • Stacey Campbell
    • Steve Shultz
    • Steven Furtick
    • Stovall Weems
    • Sunday Adelaja
    • TBN
    • The Elijah List
    • The Passion Bible
    • Theo Wolmarans
    • Todd Bentley
    • Toronto Blessing / Brownsville Revival
    • Warfare Prayer
    • Warfare Worship
    • William Branham

    You can read a lot about the New Apostolic Reformation on the Spirit of Error website. Holly Pivec co-authored a book on the NAR, has written for Biola Magazine and the Christian Research Journal, and has a Master’s degree in apologetics from Biola University.

    My Conclusion

    While I always try to be impartial, my previous research into groups and individuals colors my conclusions. I’m not anti-Pentecostal, but the excesses and abuses in the movement have given me pause. I see the NAR as only the latest in a long, long line of theologically error-prone leaders, false teachers, charlatans, and demonically-inspired grifters.

    Many in the movement are quick to point out that there is an agreed-upon statement of faith in place, and that it is historically and biblically orthodox. While true, that’s often unrelated to what’s actually being taught. In fact, much of the Charismatic/Pentecostal movement is characterized by ideas that are theologically questionable at best and, at worst, are simply lies. Most of the recent growth of Christianity around the world appears to be happening in Charismatic/Pentecostal churches, which I find disturbing… not because I’m a hater, but because most of the theologically awful stuff in my lifetime has been birthed and spread there.

    Objections

    • As we see in Ephesians 2:19-20, the church has been built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets mentioned in Scripture. Those who call themselves apostles and prophets today do so, in my opinion, foolishly. Some are only following traditions in their culture, and some are claiming authority for themselves that they weren’t given by God.
    • NAR “apostles” claim to oversee networks of churches, having spiritual authority over them. This has no basis in Scripture.
    • The primary function of the NAR is to establish God’s kingdom on earth (Dominionism). This has no basis in Scripture. In Genesis 1 mankind was given dominion over the animals, but there’s no indication that we have dominion over the earth itself, or over other humans. We have no New Testament instructions to establish dominion over our cultures. Instead, Jesus’ own words in John 18:36 tell us that His kingdom is NOT of this world.
    • NAR “prophets” and “apostles” claim to receive direct, continuing revelation from God. This can’t be substantiated, so we’re expected to take their word that it’s true. However: many of those supposed revelations are unbiblical and/or extrabiblical, which proves that they’re not from God. Instead, we see in 2 Timothy 3:16-17 that Scripture is sufficient for all.
    • Those in NAR churches are expected to submit to the leaders as having more spiritual authority. This is in direct conflict with what we see in Scripture. For example, in Acts 15:23 we see the apostles and elders calling themselves “your brothers.” In 1 Peter 5:1 we see Peter, obviously an apostle, calling himself a “fellow elder.” We have no indication in Scripture of the kind of spiritual heirarchy that the NAR is based on.

    See the complete but incomplete False Teachers List

    Disclaimer

    What matters is what the Bible teaches, and whether those who preach and teach in Jesus’ name are teaching falsely. Don’t comment or email to tell me that I’m “just wrong.” It’s a waste of your time and mine. If you have something to say, include Scripture. I am far from perfect, and I can be wrong… so I don’t do any of this lightly, and I’m open to correction.

    Don’t bother telling me how this person or that person helped you. It’s a waste of your time and mine. Nobody teaches lies and falsehoods all the time. In researching these topics, I’ve heard a LOT that I appreciated, and have been inspired by even those who are otherwise far from the truth. The number of times someone is right is irrelevant to the question of whether they also teach lies. We should appreciate anyone who teaches us the truth, but that doesn’t mean we should uncritically follow them when we see significant problems in their lives, in their ministries, and in their teaching. Neither your opinion nor mine matter here.

    If you can provide evidence that one of these people has recanted their false teaching, please let me know. I would love to amend their article to show that they have changed what they teach.

    Finally: false teachers are not our enemies. If they’re not saved, we should pray for their salvation. If they are saved, we should pray that God will lead them to teach only the truth.

    See also: a list of Bible Teachers I Can Recommend

  • What does Simon mean?

    What does Simon mean?

    Simon Peter was one of Jesus’ first disciples. His given name was Simon, sometimes spelled Symeon. Simon is the English rendering of the Hebrew name Shimon. Shimon comes from the Hebrew word shema.

    Shema (also shama) technically means “to hear” but, like many ancient Hebrew words, it suggests much more than that. It means to listen, to understand, and to respond…and more.

    You may be familiar with Deuteronomy 6:4-7, which are very significant words for observant Jews:

    Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one. Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength.

    The first word is “hear,” which is shema. It instructs the hearer to not only listen and understand, but to respond appropriately. Below is a great video explanation of Shema from The Bible Project…it’s worth watching again and again.

    When you hear the name Simon, remember to hear what God says, and to understand it, and to do it.

    Thanks to Drew for this question.

    Related Articles:

  • Was Junia a Female Apostle?

    Was Junia a Female Apostle?

    Let’s look at Romans 16:7.

    Greet Andronicus and Junia, my fellow Jews who have been in prison with me. They are outstanding among the apostles, and they were in Christ before I was.

    Two questions about this passage have been debated for many years:

    1. Was Junia a man or a woman?
    2. Was Junia an apostle?

    Some would ask, “Who cares?” Well, the reason this is debated – even among non-scholars – is that the passage may show that women could be apostles in the early church. This would undermine those who believe that women shouldn’t teach men, or be in authority over men. If the Bible says that a woman was an apostle, as the argument goes, there’s no reason that a woman can’t be a pastor today.

    My conclusions about Junia are entirely unrelated to the question of Christian women in leadership. My conclusions are – as they should be – based on the evidence, and not on some more modern argument about the implications of the text. If the text tells of a woman apostle, so be it. If not, so be it. Our doctrine and practice should come from the Scriptures. So what does the evidence show?

    Unfortunately, the evidence isn’t clear.

    What is an apostle? Would Junia qualify as an apostle?

    If the Bible specifically said that only men could be apostles, that would settle the issue. The Bible doesn’t say that. The Greek word translated “apostle” is apostolos. It only appears in the New Testament, and it means a delegate, or a messenger, sent forth with orders. That could be anybody: a man or woman, a child, or even an angel (though the word used for an angel would more likely be angelos, which means “messenger”). Apostolos is usually applied to Jesus’ twelve disciples, but is also applied to others. For an example of how the word simply means “messenger,” see John 13:16: Very truly I tell you, no servant is greater than his master, nor is a messenger greater than the one who sent him. The word translated “messenger” is apostolos. Here are more examples of apostolos in the New Testament:

    • After Judas betrayed Jesus and killed himself, the eleven remaining disciples chose a replacement. As we see in Acts 1:21-22, they had specific criteria in mind: Therefore it is necessary to choose one of the men who have been with us the whole time the Lord Jesus was living among us, beginning from John’s baptism to the time when Jesus was taken up from us. There were apparently a number of people who witnessed Jesus’ entire ministry. Junia may have been among them. They chose Matthias.
    • Paul was an apostle as well. He referred to himself as an apostle because Jesus appeared to him personally, and commissioned him personally. This is considered a unique situation in Scripture. Paul also wrote that he demonstrated “the marks of a true apostle, including signs, wonders and miracles” in 2 Corinthians 12:12. This suggests that apostles exhibited certain supernatural actions or abilities that could be identified by those who witnessed them.
    • Barnabas is called an apostle in Acts 14:4.
    • Titus and a number of others are called apostles in 2 Corinthians 8:23.
    • Apollos is called an apostle in 1 Corinthians 4:9.
    • Epaphroditus is called an apostle in Philippians 2:25.
    • Jesus is called an apostle in Hebrews 3:1. Some find this odd, as they believe an apostle must be a follower of Jesus…but the word simply describes a person who has been sent with a message. This obviously describes Jesus (as in John 12:49).

    These people are variously interpreted, in English, to have been “messengers” and “representatives” and “emissaries.” Could a woman, based on the above information, be considered an apostle? It appears so. There’s no passage that limits this to men, and nobody seems troubled by the idea that a number of women witnessed Jesus’ ministry from His baptism to his resurrection. If Junia was a woman, it seems reasonable to conclude that she might have been an apostle.

    Was Junia a woman?

    Ideally, we could just look up other biblical references to Junia and find out. Romans 16:7 is the only biblical reference to Junia, so we get no help there. The Greek construction of the name could be useful…if it was written after the ninth century. Because the accent marks that would tell us Junia’s sex don’t appear in ancient manuscripts, we get no help there, either. The consensus among the early church fathers appears to be that Junia was a woman. Later writers say that Junia is a man’s name, but by “later” we mean those writing in the twelfth century. We should, of course, prefer the earlier references to the later ones…so it’s preferable to consider the early consensus more reliable. Being diligent, we can also look for the name Junia in extrabiblical texts from that time period. If Junia was a common woman’s name and was never used in the literature for a man, we could say with some confidence that Paul’s friend Junia was a woman. Unfortunately, we simply don’t have much information from other documents. There are no instances of Junias (a masculine spelling of the same name) as a man’s name in Greek literature, while there are three of Junia as a woman.

    While it seems safe to say that Junia was probably a woman, we can’t say it with the kind of certainty we’d prefer.

    Was Junia an apostle?

    Based on the definition of an apostle, there’s no textual basis for saying that a woman, including Junia, could not have been an apostle.

    Why the debate?

    Because so many consider the idea of women in (or not in) ministry so important, and because our information about Junia is inconclusive, this information hasn’t settled the issue. We need to go back to the text. The Greek phrase translated “outstanding among the apostles” is episemos en apostolos. This can be understood in two different ways:

    1. The apostles knew Andronicus and Junia well, or
    2. Of all of the apostles in the early church, Andronicus and Junia were prominent apostles.

    The text itself isn’t conclusive. I studied Greek in college, and have used Greek language tools in the decades since, but I’m no Greek scholar. It’s difficult for a layperson to draw conclusions about which translation most accurately reflects Paul’s intent, because most (including myself) lack sufficient experience with ancient Greek. Scholars differ, so we don’t really know whether Paul meant that Junia was an outstanding apostle (when compared with other apostles) or that Junia was simply well-known among those who were apostles. Apparently, this is an issue that we may never settle.

    I think I should mention Daniel Wallace here. He is currently a professor of New Testament Studies at Dallas Theological Seminary. His Greek grammar is a standard college and seminary textbook. He’s the senior New Testament editor of the NET Bible (which appears to be a very good translation), and he is also the Executive Director for the Center for the Study of New Testament Manuscripts. In other words, he is a very well-known and respected scholar. Wallace believes that Junia was probably a woman, but that she and Andronicus were simply well-known by those who were apostles. I respect his opinion on the matter, as I know nobody better able to address the question of Greek grammar. Some will disagree, and – according to Wallace himself – maybe they should. We simply can’t make a final determination at this point.

    Implications: what if Junia was an apostle?

    Let’s say that Junia was an apostle. What would that mean? Well, it would mean that Junia (based on the definition of apostolos) was sent, by someone in authority, to deliver a message. This could be as simple as being a witness of Jesus’ ministry (sharing the gospel with others) or it could mean being a traveling evangelist, or it could mean that Junia was a local church leader as in 2 Corinthians 8:23.

    Some believe the admission that Junia was probably a woman and likely an apostle is problematic, because Paul told Timothy that he doesn’t allow a woman to teach or assume authority over a man. They consider this a universal statement of the way God wants things to be. Others believe that Paul’s instructions to Timothy were prescriptive and not universal. As evidence that God uses women in positions of spiritual and political authority over men, they cite the many women of the Bible who taught men, and ruled over them… including some women that Paul mentions specifically. Having studied the issue broadly, I can’t conclude that Paul was speaking of all women, in all situations. Judah didn’t only have kings, for example. Athaliah ruled for six years. Deborah was a prophet, and Judge over the nation of Israel. Huldah was a prophet. Anna worked in the Temple, and taught people, both men and women, about the Messiah. You may read a bit more about that here: Does God Use Women in Ministry?.

    Hat tip to David, who sent in this question.