What is it?
The KJVO controversy is about whether Christians should consider only the King James Version of the Bible to be reliable and trustworthy. While there are a variety of views within the KJVO movement, the basic idea is simple: no other Bible will do.
The King James Only movement is largely built on the claim that modern Bibles are doctrinally corrupt… that they have strayed from responsible and accurate translation of the Greek texts. There are a variety of other claims in the movement. Here are a few:
- The KJV is the only true word of God.
- The KJV is the only English translation that can be trusted.
- The KJV contains no errors.
- The KJV was supernaturally translated by God.
- The KJV is more perfect than the manuscripts from which it was translated.
- The KJV contains no errors or problems with translation.
- To understand God’s Word, everyone on earth should learn English…so they can read the KJV.
- Any deviation from the KJV is wrong, and may create doctrinal errors.
- Translators (and possibly readers) of modern Bibles have a sinister ulterior motive.
- Modern Bibles are a perversion of God’s Word.
- Modern Bibles like the NASB and NIV are part of a satanic conspiracy to lead the world astray.
- People who use other Bibles are not Christians.
The Inconsistency
The King James Bible was created by, and created for, Anglicans. In my decades of conversation with these KJVO folks, I’ll bet that not one of them would ever consider becoming Anglican… yet they promote the Anglican Bible as if the Anglican Church produced the purest, most accurate, most inspired translation in history.
That’s pretty inconsistent.
Which KJV?
There are a number of different versions of the King James Version. Most KJVO advocates do not use the version finished in 1611, but the Blayney version from 1769. Between the two are revisions from 1613, 1629, 1638, and 1762. After many years of discussing this issue, no KJVO person has suggested to me that one is better than the other. This is a serious problem for their point of view, as each differs from the others.
Errors in the KJV
Most KJVO advocates claim that the KJV is better than all other Bibles because it alone is without error. This is absurd, and demonstrably false. The errors in the KJV are too numerous to list here, but it only takes one error to prove them wrong. I’ve made note of a few that should be persuasive for anyone willing to consider the evidence. Unfortunately, I’ve never met a KJVO advocate that was willing to consider the evidence… they usually run away from it. If you’re a KJVO person who wants to discuss the evidence, please leave a comment!
Unicorns
Most adults realize that unicorns don’t really exist. KJVO advocates must overlook the nine times that the word “unicorn” appears in the KJV: in Numbers 23:22, Numbers 24:8, Deuteronomy 33:17, Job 39:9, Job 39:10, Psalm 22:21, Psalm 29:6, Psalm 92:10, and Isaiah 34:7 (read on Biblegateway). The Hebrew word is RE-EM, and probably means an auroch or other, now extinct, wild bull.
Easter / Passover
In Acts 12:4, the KJV mistranslates Pascha as Easter, rather than Passover. I’ve written more about this in Easter in the KJV.
Jupiter/Zeus, Mercury/Hermes
In Acts 14:12, the KJV says that the people in Lystra called Paul “Mercury” and Barnabas “Jupiter.” This is in spite of the fact that the Greek uses the words “Zeus” and “Hermes.”
Don’t trust the demons
In Acts 16 we read about a young lady, possessed by a demon, who followed Paul and Silas. The demon – according to the KJV – said that they were servants of the most high God, which shew unto us the way of salvation. Unfortunately, this is simply wrong. The Greek (the original language of the New Testament) doesn’t say “the way of salvation.” It says “a way of salvation.” The Greek word is Hodos, which means “a way” (see the definition in context). The demon wasn’t agreeing that Paul and Silas taught the only way to be saved… it suggested that they taught one of many ways. The King James is simply inaccurate here.
Listen to the KJV translators
Most Bibles have a preface, in which the translation team explains their motives and methodology. The KJV is no different. The 1611 version of the KVJ had an extensive preface, removed from later versions. Read the full preface. In it, the translators themselves demolish the KJVO controversy:
- They didn’t intend to make a new translation, but to improve on previous ones
- They acknowledged that previous Bibles were “the word of God” despite containing “imperfections and blemishes”
- They wrote that translations will never be infallible.
- They noted the supremacy of the original manuscripts over any translation
- They wrote that one should not object to the continual process of correcting and improving English translations of the Bible
- They were often unsure how to translate specific words or phrases
- They did not always translate the same Greek or Hebrew words into the same English words
The Greek texts from which the KJV were translated come from around the 11th century. Bible translators have access to those, of course, and far more that have been discovered in the past 400 years. Most modern Bibles are translated from manuscripts that are 700-1000 years older… far closer to the original documents, and less prone to that changes that naturally come from copying errors and insertions.
Questions and Objections
But it’s so beautiful
Some people, especially those who grew up reading Renaissance literature like the works of Shakespeare, appreciate the KJV because of its more ‘poetic’ nature. There’s nothing wrong with this. If you like the KJV, read it.
Unfortunately, when someone suggests that more modern Bibles might be more helpful to those less familiar with older English, a typical response is that they should simply become more educated. This isn’t helpful, of course. A similar argument could be made about any translation, including the King James: ‘What’s wrong with the Latin Vulgate? If you can’t understand Latin, that’s your problem. You should study more so you can understand God’s word clearly.’ No, that’s a dumb argument, especially for those who aren’t native English speakers.
Even those who are more well-read can struggle with the language of the KJV. Here’s James 3:1, for example:
My brethren, be not many masters, knowing that we shall receive the greater condemnation.
Because the common usage of words change over time, this verse may lead some to believe that it’s endorsing slavery (that some should indeed be masters), or that slave owners (like James?) will receive greater condemnation than others, or that Christians in general will receive greater condemnation than those who are not “brethren.”
The point of translation is to make sure people can understand God’s Word. If you like the KJV, great. Read it. If someone else struggles with it, a more current translation will serve them better.
But the NIV takes out stuff
The primary target of KJVO folks is the New International Version (NIV). Their claim is that the NIV translators have removed crucial words and phrases from the Bible, undermining God’s word and leading unwitting people astray. There is a very serious flaw in this argument: they invariably use the KJV as the standard. Any word or phrase that differs from the King James is then suspect.
Is this logical? Of course not. The KJV translators themselves would object to this method. They would never consider the KJV to be the standard by which all future Bibles should be judged. Instead, they would recommend exactly what the NIV translators have done: go back to the manuscripts, in their original languages, and try to improve on the Bibles that already exist.
Trickery: comparing the KJV and NIV
The KJVO folks like to compare verses side by side, to show how the NIV (or other Bible) differs from the “right Bible” – that is, the KJV. That seems reasonable, on the surface. It’s a serious problem, however. It presumes that the KJV is always right, and that other Bibles are corrupt because, well, they’re not the KJV. The proper approach is not to compare one translation or version with another, but to compare all of them with all available ancient manuscripts.
There are more scholarly ways to describe this controversy, involving more complex considerations like different manuscript families, formal vs dynamic equivalence, and so on. This article is meant as an overview… a summary of the controversy and why I believe the KJVO folks have no real argument. If you have specific questions, feel free to ask them.
What I am NOT saying
I am not suggesting that there is anything wrong with the King James Version of the Bible. In fact, I recommend it. One could read the KJV and learn all they need to know about being in a right relationship with God. I’m not criticizing the KJV here. I’m only criticizing the idea that the KJV is in any way superior to every other quality Bible. I agree with the KJV translators: it’s good, but not perfect. Those who claim that the KJV is better than any other Bible must not only claim it, but also demonstrate it. Simply put: they cannot.